Skip to main content Skip to search Skip to main navigation
Practice management

The human factor in implantology: safe surgery through checklists and mental preparation

Checklists, mental dress rehearsals and surgical reports written in advance: Prof. Eik Schiegnitz shows how the human factor can be eliminated as a source of error in implantology.

Published on

When an implant sits in the wrong position or is lost, the cause is rarely the material. Prof. Dr. Dr. Eik Schiegnitz, for many years head of the Section for Implantology and Augmentation Surgery at the University Medical Centre Mainz and now also working in a practice in Wiesbaden, describes on the podcast Queens & Sons of Dentistry how he systematically eliminates the "human factor" as a source of error — with checklists, consistent preparation and a mental routine that anticipates every operation several times over.

Lessons from aviation

Schiegnitz describes himself as the greatest fan of the human factor. His reference model is aviation: before a passenger boards a commercial aircraft, the pilot is already sitting in the cockpit working through a checklist — are the engines functioning, has the aircraft been refuelled, is the team complete? In this way aviation has become incredibly safe: from times in which — put pointedly — almost every fifth aircraft crashed, to a risk today that is vanishingly small and which Schiegnitz puts at 0.0024 per cent. The decisive step was the elimination of the human factor as a source of error.

For when errors occur in medicine or in aviation, it is almost always the human being who causes them — technical faults are the exception. If an implant sits in the wrong position or is lost, that mostly has nothing to do with the implant screw, but with an error on the part of the surgeon. Anyone who has internalised this thought — that one is oneself the all-decisive factor for the patient's success — restructures the entire workflow.

Success begins in the patient consultation

According to Schiegnitz, success in implantology does not begin with the insertion of the implant, but already in the patient consultation. A checklist is completed there as well — mentally, and better still in writing: is a 3D image available? Does a plan exist? Has the required implant been ordered? Are the necessary biomaterials in stock? And is the team in a position to carry out precisely this operation on that day?

The following step comes the evening before: back to the desk once more, going through the next day's programme and mentally checking the list. The standard Schiegnitz formulates in doing so is remarkably personal: am I so well prepared that tomorrow I would also operate on my own mother? That humility applies to every patient — irrespective of how easy or difficult the procedure is.

Seven mental operations before the first incision

Schiegnitz sums up the result of this routine in a memorable figure: every patient he operates on he has previously operated on at least seven times in his mind. That is why he is essentially never nervous when entering the operating theatre. He knows his plan A — and should it not work, plan B, plan C and plan D are already at the back of his mind. In medicine one is dealing with human beings; the anatomy may be different from what the radiograph shows. Anyone prepared for that can move quite calmly to the next plan and knows that there is always still a last way out.

The surgical report before the operation

As a concrete tip — formulated on the podcast as a "hack" — Schiegnitz recommends writing surgical reports in advance: preparing the operation in such a way that the report is already written before the procedure. Anyone who has mentally set down what he is going to do has thought the entire operation through considerably better. Documenting only afterwards is, considered from the point of view of the human factor, in fact already an omission. The report prepared in advance then only has to be adjusted afterwards if something actually went differently from what was planned.

The same care in clinic and practice

Schiegnitz's attitude to his own move from university medicine into private practice is noteworthy: this systematic approach is not switched off merely because everything supposedly has to go faster in practice — even though it means more work. He applies the routines there with exactly the same consistency, every day and every evening. What he implemented over years at the university he takes with him into the practice; the aspiration to optimise oneself from A to Z remains unaffected by the place of treatment. The message to the profession is thus clear: patient safety does not arise in the moment of the procedure, but in the structure and discipline of the days beforehand.

#Qualitätsmanagement #Patientensicherheit #OP-Vorbereitung
Ustomed Podcast – Queens and Sons of Dentistry · #127

Prof. Eik Schiegnitz - Vom Klinikalltag in die eigene Praxis

Guest: Prof. Dr. Dr. Eik Schiegnitz