Around 100 implants a year are placed by the practice of Dr Maximilian Fuhrmann – with a treatment focus on periodontology and restorative dentistry, so that considerably more teeth are preserved than replaced. Ten to twenty per cent of these implants are now made of ceramic. In episode 129 of the Queens & Sons of Dentistry podcast, the dentist, who has been practising for more than 14 years, describes how the decision between titanium and zirconia is reached in his practice – and which cases have stayed with him in particular.
When ceramic is used
According to Fuhrmann, demand increasingly arises on the patient side: more and more people actively ask whether there is an alternative to titanium. Three motivations present themselves regularly: the wish for a metal-free restoration, highly aesthetic demands and a more holistically oriented attitude in which a solution in the body that is as “interference-free” as possible is desired. The dentist formulates his indication clearly: where there is concern about potential intolerances, the practice generally opts for ceramic – provided that the bone supply offers a load-bearing basis in height and width without extensive augmentation being necessary. In principle, every restoration is discussed individually with the patient and the solution that is best from the practitioner’s point of view is offered.
Case example: titanium intolerance and sticky bone augmentation
As a key moment, Fuhrmann describes in the podcast a patient who had had a titanium stimulation test carried out – with the result of an intolerance. His wish: ceramic only. The bone conditions, however, were rather narrow, so augmentation was required. The sticky bone technique was used in combination with a fibrin adhesive from surgery, which comes from the medical manufacturer Baxter and is obtained directly from the company rather than through the dental trade. The material, delivered freeze-dried and stored refrigerated, consists of two components – fibrinogen and thrombin – and simulates blood coagulation. Mixed with autologous or xenogeneic augmentation material, it produces a stable, mouldable mass that Fuhrmann compares to chewing gum: it cannot be washed out, adapts precisely to the morphology of the defect and becomes additionally firmer through the bound blood. A membrane is therefore not strictly necessary. The technique goes back to an Italian dentist who developed it around 20 years ago. The result was convincing: the patient “got exactly what he wanted” – and in outstanding quality.
Case example: immediate implant placement in the aesthetic zone
Fuhrmann also remembers well the first ceramic implant of the system currently in use: an anterior tooth had to be extracted, and the patient was quickly “fired up” about the new restoration. The implant was placed immediately after the tooth was removed, but was not loaded immediately. Particularly in the aesthetic zone and with the thinner biotype present, the white colour of the implant played out its appeal – there, where a dark implant body could shine through in the event of bone loss. Prosthetically the case was certainly demanding, but in the end everything worked very well: “everyone was grateful”.
Placing costs in a transparent context
On costs, Fuhrmann differentiates by system: the ceramic implant currently in use is cheaper than the ceramic system previously employed, but is still above titanium – roughly 150 to 200 euros gross in additional costs. Since implants, like prosthetics from an external laboratory, are passed on one to one as a pass-through item and storage costs may not be added on, this difference reaches the patient directly. With the system previously used, a single implant alone cost around 600 euros – with several implants this adds up to an entirely different order of magnitude. Accordingly, it is always necessary to weigh up what is financially bearable.
The benchmark: one’s own family
How convinced the implantologist is of his choice of material is shown by his answer to the question of which restoration he would recommend to his own parents: where the bone supply is sufficient and no major augmentation is required, a ceramic implant – “they get the white one”. As regards subjective perception, by contrast, he sees no difference between the materials: a foreign-body sensation can occur with any implant, because the proprioception of the natural tooth with its fibre apparatus is missing; much depends on individual psychology. Individual consultation therefore remains the core of every material decision.